Stockwoods successfully defends $150 million Consumer Protection Act class proceeding 

Stockwoods lawyers Paul Le Vay, Carlo Di Carlo and Caitlin Milne successfully resisted certification of a class proceeding brought against Bell Canada on the behalf of prisoners from Ontario facilities.  The claim related to the rates that Bell charged prisoners while providing telecommunications services at prison facilities.  The class pleaded breach of the Consumer Protection Act, unconscionability, unjust enrichment and breach of the Telecommunications Act as against Bell. 

Bell denied these allegations.  It argued that the class failed to plead a reasonable cause of action.  It also brought a cross motion urging the Ontario Superior Court to decline to exercise jurisdiction because the CRTC was the appropriate forum in which these issues should be litigated.

Justice Perell agreed with Bell.  He found that the Telecommunications Act claim was not a reasonable cause of action and that the remainder of the causes of action dealt with issues within the subject matter expertise of the CRTC and should be left to that body to decide.

The decision is a reaffirmation of the Ontario Superior Court’s deferential approach to matters within the expertise of the CRTC.  It also reflects the trend in case law for courts to assess the substance of a claim, not simply the causes of action asserted, in assessing jurisdiction.

A copy of the decision can be found here.

Carlo Di Carlo to talk on Commercial List advocacy

Stockwoods awarded Litigation Boutique of the Year by Benchmark Canada

Stockwoods successfully defends $150 million Consumer Protection Act class proceeding 

Stockwoods wins application protecting the privilege of an investment trust

Stockwoods Lawyers Speak at Digital Evidence for Lawyers CPD

MARCH ISSUE OF THE STOCKWOODS ADMINISTRATIVE & REGULATORY LAW CASE REVIEW

Brian Gover receives Law Society Medal

Stockwoods Obtains Stay of Proceedings in $80 Million Commercial Action

JANUARY ISSUE OF THE STOCKWOODS ADMINISTRATIVE & REGULATORY LAW CASE REVIEW

Stockwoods Lawyers Acting on Behalf of the Plaintiffs in the Indexed Finance Class Action

Steve Aylward wins Emerging Excellence Award from Toronto Lawyers Association

SEPTEMBER ISSUE OF THE STOCKWOODS ADMINISTRATIVE AND REGULATORY LAW CASE REVIEW

Fred Schumann Speaks to the Lawyer’s Daily about Sealing Orders and Publication Bans

Frank Marrocco Joins Stockwoods

12 Stockwoods lawyers recognized by Best Lawyers in Canada
- Find a Lawyer -

Frank Marrocco

Paul Le Vay

Brian Gover

Luisa Ritacca

Brendan van Niejenhuis

Samuel M. Robinson

Andrea Gonsalves

Gerald Chan

Nader R. Hasan

Edward (Ted) Marrocco

Justin Safayeni

Fredrick Schumann

Carlo Di Carlo

Stephen Aylward

Ryann Atkins

Karen Bernofsky

Gillian Moore

Dragana Rakic

Spencer Bass

Alexandra Heine

Yadesha Satheaswaran

Ephry Mudryk