Stockwoods’ lawyers represent the Criminal Lawyers’ Association in an important solicitor-client privilege decision at the SCC

Today, the Supreme Court of Canada released its decision in Alberta (Information and Privacy Commissioner) v. University of Calgary, 2016 SCC 53, a case that will have far-reaching implications for the protection of solicitor-privilege.  Stockwoods’ lawyers Brian Gover, Justin Safayeni and Carlo Di Carlo represented the intervener, Criminal Lawyers Association in this appeal.

This was a case dealing with s. 56(3) of the Alberta Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act which allowed the Information and Privacy Commission of Alberta to order the production of documents  “[d]espite . . . any privilege of the law of evidence”.

Applying Blood Tribe, the SCC ultimately concluded that this was not sufficiently clear language to be interpreted as abrogating privilege.  The court held that this is consistent with the view of solicitor-client privilege as a fundamental policy of the law.   This conclusion was also supported by a contextual analysis of the statute, as the court noted that:

  • This interpretation is consistent with the principle that statutes should be read as a whole, as s. 27 of this act unequivocally establishes that a public body may refuse to disclose “information that is subject to any type of legal privilege, including solicitor‑client privilege”;
  • This interpretation is coherent as “privilege[s] of the law of evidence”, referenced in s. 56(3), are a narrower category falling within the scope of the broader category of “legal privileges”, as laid out in s. 27(1); and
  • Given its fundamental importance, one would expect that if the legislature had intended to set aside solicitor‑client privilege, it would have legislated safeguards to ensure that solicitor‑client privileged documents are not disclosed in a manner that compromises the substantive right.

Click here to see the factum submitted by Stockwoods on the behalf of the CLA.

Stockwoods Recognized in Lexpert 2024

Ted Marrocco speaks to the Association of Business Immigration Lawyers about Privacy and Online Risk Management

Paul Le Vay, Brian Gover and Carlo di Carlo Recognized in List of Leading 500 Lawyers in Canada

RYANN ATKINS JOINS THE PARTNERSHIP AT STOCKWOODS

DECEMBER ISSUE OF THE STOCKWOODS ADMINISTRATIVE AND REGULATORY LAW CASE REVIEW 

Jury Returns Homicide Verdict in Soleiman Faqiri Inquest

STOCKWOODS PARTNERS SUCCESSFULLY APPEAL DEFAMATION JUDGMENT

Ted Marrocco discusses Digital Assets at the Ontario Bar Association

Andrea Gonsalves and Luisa Ritacca speak on Commissions Advocacy

Stockwoods partners participate in the OPD 18th Annual National Forum on Administrative Law and Practice

OCTOBER ISSUE OF THE STOCKWOODS ADMINISTRATIVE & REGULATORY LAW CASE REVIEW

Chambers Canada recognizes Stockwoods’ for professional excellence

Stockwoods listed in Best Lawyers Canada for 2024

JULY ISSUE OF THE STOCKWOODS ADMINISTRATIVE & REGULATORY LAW CASE REVIEW

Ted Marrocco speaks at the Toronto Lawyers Association “Top Tips for Advocates” series
- Find a Lawyer -