Divisional Court upholds absolute liability rule for positive drug tests in horse racing

Stockwoods lawyers Brendan van Niejenhuis and Fredrick Schumann successfully persuaded the Divisional Court to dismiss a challenge to rules promulgated by the Ontario Racing Commission to combat the use of performance-enhancing substances in horse racing.

The rules, implemented in 2008, create an absolute liability offence by a trainer where the trainer’s horse tests positive for a prohibited substance, while permitting evidence of due diligence by the trainer to be introduced at the penalty phase.  In Shakes v. Ontario Racing Commission, 2012 ONSC 4229, Swinton J. (for a unanimous panel of the Divisional Court) agreed that the presumption against absolute liability offences found in cases such as R. v. Sault Ste. Marie, [1978] 2 S.C.R. 1299, did not mean that the legislature had to explicitly grant the Commission power to create absolute liability offences in its Rules.  As a result, the Divisional Court upheld the penalty imposed on the trainer as a result of his horse’s positive test for caffeine.

Stockwoods client successful in Charter challenge to Ontario “Ag-gag” legislation

MARCH ISSUE OF THE STOCKWOODS ADMINISTRATIVE AND REGULATORY LAW CASE REVIEW

Stockwoods Recognized in Lexpert 2024

Ted Marrocco speaks to the Association of Business Immigration Lawyers about Privacy and Online Risk Management

Paul Le Vay, Brian Gover and Carlo di Carlo Recognized in List of Leading 500 Lawyers in Canada

RYANN ATKINS JOINS THE PARTNERSHIP AT STOCKWOODS

DECEMBER ISSUE OF THE STOCKWOODS ADMINISTRATIVE AND REGULATORY LAW CASE REVIEW 

Jury Returns Homicide Verdict in Soleiman Faqiri Inquest

STOCKWOODS PARTNERS SUCCESSFULLY APPEAL DEFAMATION JUDGMENT

Ted Marrocco discusses Digital Assets at the Ontario Bar Association

Andrea Gonsalves and Luisa Ritacca speak on Commissions Advocacy

Stockwoods partners participate in the OPD 18th Annual National Forum on Administrative Law and Practice

OCTOBER ISSUE OF THE STOCKWOODS ADMINISTRATIVE & REGULATORY LAW CASE REVIEW

Chambers Canada recognizes Stockwoods’ for professional excellence

Stockwoods listed in Best Lawyers Canada for 2024
- Find a Lawyer -